Sunday, March 4, 2012

Real Etate Market Trying to Level Off

            Flat but not flatlining.      
That might be a reasonable assessment of the Central Oregon real estate market for 2011 and the early months of 2012 as indexed by sales of single family homes.
In fact by a remarkable coincidence the number of 2011 single family home sales in Bend, by far the largest regional sub-market, were dead even with 2010—at 1,690 for each year. Bend accounts for nearly 60% of all regional single family sales followed by Redmond with 22.68%.
Sales of distresed properties throughout the reigon continue to dominate, ranging from nearly 70% (68.09%) of Redmond sales to a low of 14.29% in the small Sunriver sub-market. In Bend, there were 883 short sales or bank owned single family sales, or 52.25% of the total.
Even more dramatic, as of March 1 distressed properties accounted for more than 80% of pending or contingent sales in Crook County (Prineville and the area); LaPine and Jefferson County (Madras). The percentage was 68.93% in Bend; 75.66% in Redmond and 55.56% in Sisters.
Sunriver had the lowest rate of pending/contingent distressed properties at 41.18% as well as in 2011 total sales, at 14.29%.
Sunriver leads and Sisters lags  the market over 10 years
Looking at price trends year-to-year, median prices declined in all but one sub-market (LaPine up 1.75%). Bend’s median at year end had fallen by only $1,000, from $191,000 to $190,000, or minus 0.52%.  The largest drop was in Sisters, where the median slumped to $201,000 from $233,750 in 2010, or 14.01%.
Going back to a longer-term historical perspective, single family prices in three of the regional sub-markets have fallen below the median at the end of 2001.  All seven of the submarkets were substantially off the 2006 bubble-year highs, by a range of 46% to nearly 60%.
Sunriver was the strongest market since 2001 with the median price up 29.53%, and had the smallest decline, off 34.78%, since the 2006 peak.  Sunriver also topped the sub-market median price at $375,000 in 2011, as it has for every year since 2001.
The small Sisters market lagged the region for the past 10 years, with a median price at the end of 2011 of $201,000, or 14.47% below 2001. The past year also marked the second consecutive year that Sisters prices were below the 2001 level.
The largest drop from the 2006 peak was in Crook County, down 59.92%, followed by Sisters at 56.35%. The best price performance since the bubble burst was in Sunriver, a drop of only 34.78%, followed by Bend, down 46.01%
Distressed properties skew a "normal" market analysis
Perhaps one of the more surprising statistics in the current market is the existing inventory of active single family listings.  In early March there were 439 active listings in Bend, which is only slightly more than a three-month supply when calculated by the industry standard of averaging the previous 12 month sales. By contrast as the market collapse accelerated in the 2007-2010 period the supply of active listings in Bend was more than 13 months at one point.
Interpreting the significance of the lower inventory level is a subjective process. In an otherwise "normal" cycle the low inventory would be considered a healthy sign of a recovering market. But in this abnormal cycle an important variable is the potential overhang of the widely-dubbed  "shadow inventory" of distressed properties that could be hitting the market.
Another factor in the lower inventory could likely be homeowners who are not under any pressure to sell waiting for better market conditions.
One extreme example of the market drag created by the foreclosure process is an expensive home in a gated community near Bend.  The owner paid $2,275,000 in 2004 with a loan of more than $1.6 million.  The lender has issued three notices of default for a trustee's sale since the owner stopped payments of more than $9,000 per month in December of 2008. But all scheduled sales have been canceled, the last in November of 2011.
Meanwhile as the owner essentially walked away without winterizing the home it's now in disrepair with at least tens of thousands of dollars needed to bring it back to original condition.








SINGLE FAMILY HOMES (on lots less than 1 acre)
Central Oregon-Bend MSA*
TOTAL UNITS SOLD
SOLD as
SHORT SALES/REOs
PENDING/
CONTINGENT SALES
ACTIVE LISTINGS
SHORT/REO
ACTIVE LISTINGS


Town or area
Total units sold
Including short sales and foreclosures (REOs)

% change total units sold
Short sales/bank owned (REO) units Sold
%
Short/
REO units sold

Pending or
contingent sales(all)  /PendContshortREO

% short&
REO of total pending or
contingent
Total active
listings
Active short/ REO listings

% short /
REO
of active listings

2001
2009
2010
2011
2010-2011
2011
2011
Mar 1 2012
Mar 1 2012
Mar 1 2012
Mar 1 2012
Mar1 2012
Bend
1,419
1,544
1,690
1,690
0.00%
883
53.25%
428/295
68.93%
439
83
19.39%
Redmond
519
629
727
658
9.49%
448
68.09%
152/115
75.66%
152
41
26.97%
Sisters
90
70
88
95
+7.95%
28
29.47%
18/10
55.56%
71
5
7.04%
Sunriver
170
80
92
98
+6.50%
14
14.29%
17/7
41.18%
117
7
5.98%
Crook Co.
127
163
221
204
-7.69%
127
62.25%
40/32
80.00%
85
17
20.00%
La Pine
17
71
64
59
-7.81%
36
61.02%
16/14
87.50%
31
15
48.39%
Jefferson Co-Madras
NA
113
120
97
-19.17%
59
60.82%
24/20
83.33%
60
23
38.33%



Town or area
MEDIAN PRICES
MEDIAN PRICE CHANGES

2001
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
% change
2010-2011
% +/-
from 2006
peak thru 2011
% change
2001-2010
Bend
168,950
279,900
352,500
345,000
289,450
212,637

191,000
190,000
-0.52%
-46.01%
+12.46%
Redmond
125,000
198,818
262,524
250,000
216,000
147,500
123,900
116,000
-6.38%
-55.81%
-7.20%
Sisters
235,000
394,250
460,500
415,000
367,450
286,250
233,750
201,000
-14.01%
-56.35%
-14.47%
Sunriver
289,500
462,500
575,000
548,547
555,738
402,000
417,500
375,000
-10.18%
-34.78%
+29.53%
Crook Co.
106,524
149,275
197,000
199,450
177,500
111,875
91,100
78,950
-13.34%
-59.92%
-15.89%
LaPine
86,000
148,500
183,250
215,000
160,000
109,000
102,450
88,200
-13.91%
-51.87%
+2.56%
Jefferson Co-Madras
NOT REPORTED
NOT REPORTED
165,080
177,950
139,950
89,900
68,700
69,900
+1.75%
-57.66%
NA-NOT REPORTED
UNTIL 2006

This information is derived from the Central Oregon Association of Realtors MLS database. It is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. MSA includes three counties of Central Oregon.

       

Monday, January 23, 2012

DesCo Planning Commission to discuss agri-tourism policy—Again!

            The Deschutes County Planning Commission has again delayed action on recommendations for dealing with regulation of events on agricultural land.
            In protracted discussion at a Jan. 12 meeting the commissioners decided not to decide and rescheduled another session for Jan. 26, again to consider “text amendments” to the county code to recommend to the three-member county commission.
            For the past several years the county has tossed around the hot potato farmland events policy. The new urgency comes as the result of Oregon Senate Bill 960 which opens the way for more “agri-tourism” events on land zoned Exclusive Farm Use.
            The county has the option through the county code text amendments to place certain restrictions on events. These can address traffic safety and security, sanitation, and noise levels, the latter which has become a significant point of contention in public testimony and the planning commission’s discussion.

Saturday, December 10, 2011

Bullish Bovine Busts Banquet--Cow Pies join Canapes

  •      A new kind of wedding crasher ?
     To some county residents attending a recent planning commission hearing  it could have made front page in a supermarket tabloid. Or maybe one of those humorous YouTube teasers  that pop up in e-mails or online news pages.
      But the speaker earnestly outlined the “smelly” scenario she warned could evolve if an errant cow marauded through a wedding on farmland.
      The comment was among an opening salvo in a back and forth dialogue Dec. 8 as the Deschutes County Planning Commission wrestled with planning staff recommendations for new “text amendments” that would allow commercial events on land zoned for exclusive farm use (EFU).
      For the most part supporters and opponents of the recommendations found some common ground in at least one idea—that it’s time “to get it done” one way or another. “It” has simmered for a contentious four years on the county’s planning agenda.
      Besides the potentially malodorous outcome laid out in the opening comments a number  of those speaking against the proposed  text amendments said noise from amplified music and traffic were their main objections. Some wanted no part of commercial events on farmland while others left open the door for compromises  to accommodate neighbors.
      As for noise, one speaker who has held weddings on his EFU property reminded those present that “farming is noisy, dusty and smelly.” He asked how a permit for six events as proposed in the “agri-tourism” amendment to the county code would create more impact than the typical farm activity.
      “Underlying the message in my testimony,” the speaker summarized, “would be to just adopt it.”
      A spokesman for the conservationist group 1000 Friends of Oregon’s regional office outlined the position that any event activity be “subordinate” to agricultural activity and “not disrupt the stability of the property.”
      Pam Hardy said 1000 Friends favored events such as “farm dinners” using agricultural products, and would like to see different standards for large and small events. Noise levels, she suggested, should be controlled by having amplified sound set back 1,000 feet from neighboring property lines or there should be a requirement that sound at the property line be no more than at conversation level. She also suggested that obtaining “waivers” from neighbors might be an option.
      Several speakers who plan or promote events, or supply equipment catering services, advocated adoption of the amendments as a way to encourage economic recovery in difficult times for business and agriculture.
      An event planner and manager emphasized that by “this going on and on we’ve lost many event based businesses,” and that events have gone elswhere, including across the Cascades.
      The text amendments proposed by county staff follow guidelines established in state legislation, SB 960, applying to “agri-tourism, HB 3280, events at wineries,  and conditional uses for private parks and events connected to home occupations.
      Weddings have been the focal point of most controversy in the county's long discussion of events on EFU land. The language of SB 960 is unclear as to whether weddings would come under the definition of "agri-tourism." 
      The staff proposal for agri-tourism would allow up to six events under a two-year limited use permit renewable after review to assure conditions had been met. Up to 18 events would be allowed on a four-year permit that would require public notice and comment for renewal.
      Events on EFU land with wineries are allowed as an “outright use” by HB 3280, The county has required that no more than 25% of a winery’s revenue be from events. The county can also require standards for “health and safety.”
      The other options to hold events on farmland would be under state legislation pertaining to private parks and home occupations, both of which would require the county to issue a conditional use permit.
      At issue with the private parks option is the definition of “recreation” use required by state law. County planning director Nick Lelack noted that the state Department of Land Conservation and Development has recommended that the county “tighten” any amendments so that events would not be permitted under more than a single measure.
      Should the county proceed with allowing events under the private parks method Lelack noted it could become a statewide “test case.” Crook and Benton counties have approved events in private parks without having the decisions appealed to the state level.
      Lelack said DLCD has suggested in requested  comments on proposed text amendments that the county  “don’t pursue” allowing events under the private parks or home occupation provisions.
      After closing nearly three hours of staff presentation, public comments and discussion, planning commissioners voted to close the oral comment period but leave open the opportunity for written comments until Jan. 5.
      During that time commissioners will weigh public testimony and written comments along with suggestions from the state Department of Land Conservation and Development in an attempt to fashion a final version to consider at their next session Jan. 12. From there the commission decision would go to the Board of County Commissions for action, which could include additional hearings.

Summary documents submitted by the county planning staff: